Today I ate a hamburger from HB Burger, a semi-new burger joint here in Manhattan. It wasn’t the best burger I’ve ever had, but I enjoyed eating it. It was cooked on a flat grill (like a griddle) and served on a soft bun. On my walk back to the office after that lunch I had an ah-ha moment (this is where Oprah comes in – she has recurring ah-ha moments). I remembered one of the first burgers I ever ate. One of the finest burgers I ever ate. It was from Harry’s Grill in Deerfield, IL. Harry’s Grill has had at least four name changes and six different owners since I was a kid, but that’s beside the point. Harry’s Grill was our neighborhood…I’ll call it “diner,” for lack of a better term. Everything was cooked on a flat grill at Harry’s. The burgers would sizzle away as you sat at the counter and watched. When they were done, the cook would toss the burger on a plate and slide them across the counter to you. If you didn’t stop the sliding plate, the burger would be on your lap. This was one of my first burger experiences, one that I have not thought about in a very, very long time, until today.
Over these last 20-something years, I have tried a variety of burgers, from Mushroom Swiss Burgers from Murphy’s in Champaign, IL and burgers from Free State Brewery in Lawrence, KS to Duck Burgers from Cindy Pawlcyn in Napa to Cuban Chorizo Burgers in Miami, and even my first Lamb Burger with Goat Cheese from Green Street Café in Coconut Grove, FL. While the toppings on burgers seem endless, the cooking methods are, well, flat grill or char grill. There have been magazine articles heralding the top burgers in the country (and I’ve enjoyed many of them) along with television shows about burgers; people who blog solely about burgers and books about the history of the burger. Where will this burger frenzy end? Will it end?
Now, fast-forward from when I was child sitting at the counter at Harry’s Grill to now. One of my favorite burgers of all time, hands down, is at Danny Meyer’s Shake Shack. It’s simple. It’s a thin, freshly ground burger cooked on a flat grill and served on a soft potato bun. I love it. It gets me every time. Long lines, hype and awards aside, I have a crush on this burger.
Today at around 2:10pm EST, it all came together for me. I was walking down 43rd Street wondering why I liked that burger form HB so much. It wasn’t all that amazing, but there was something about it. That’s when the ah-ha moment happened. It reminded me of the burger I used to eat at Harry’s Grill as a kid. Now wait, why do I love Shake Sh…. AH, THEIR BURGER IS COOKED ON FLAT GRILL TOO. AND, SERVED ON A SOFT BUN. It all came together in the blink of an eye.
While I love a good char burger, I guess it’s true: a burger cooked on a flat grill really does it for me. This is not right or wrong, but like many childhood experiences, mine and burgers came together and made their peace today.










